The War Machine

What was the purpose of this complex organization [the arrangement of conscription, military organization, civilian production, and transportation that was brought to bear to fight the first World War]? Officially it was supposed to save civilization, protect the rights of small democracies, demonstrate the superiority of Teutonic culture, beat the dirty Hun, beat the arrogant British, what have you. But the men caught in the middle came to glimpse a darker truth. "The War had become undisguisedly mechanical and inhuman," Siefgried Sassoon allows a fictional infantry officer to see. "What in earlier days had been drafts of volunteers were now droves of victims." Men on every front independently discovered their victimization. Awareness intensified as the war dragged on. In Russia it exploded in reolution. In Germany it motivated desertions and surrenders. Among the French it led to mutinies in the front lines. Among the Biritish it fostered malingering.

Whatever its otstensible purpose, the end result of the complex organization that was the efficient software of the Great War was the manufacture of corpses. This essentially industrial operation was fantasized by the generals as a "strategy of attrition." The British tried to kill Germans, the Germans tried to kill Bristish and French and so on, a "strategy" so familiar by now that it almost sounds normal. It was not normal in Europe before 1914 and no one in authority expected it to evolve, despite the pioneering lessons of the American Civil War. Once the trenches were in place, the long grave already dug (John Masefield's bitterly ironic phrase), then the war stalemated and death-making overwhelmed any rational response. "The war machine," concludes Elliot, "rooted in law, organization, production, movement, science, technical ingenuity, with its product of six thousand deaths a day over a period of 1,500 days, was the permanent and realistic factor, impervious to fantasy, only slightly altered by human variation."

[Richard Rhodes, The Making of the Atomic Bomb (Simon & Schuster, New York, 1986), pp. 102–103.]

Posted on June 19, 2005 at 12.34 by jns · Permalink
In: All, Common-Place Book